Controversy Erupts as NYC Mayoral Candidate Fundraises for UN Agency Linked to Hamas

In a move that has ignited significant political backlash, Zohran Mamdani, a leading candidate in the New York City mayoral race, recently organized a fundraising event for the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA). This agency has faced scrutiny for its alleged connections to Hamas, particularly following the October 7, 2023, attacks on Israel. The situation has drawn sharp criticism from various political figures, including Republican Congresswoman Elise Stefanik, who has labeled Mamdani an “antisemite” and condemned New York Governor Kathy Hochul for endorsing him.

Fundraising Amidst Tensions

Mamdani’s fundraising event, the “New York City Gaza 5K,” aimed to support UNRWA, which he described as a vital organization providing humanitarian aid to Palestinians in Gaza. However, the timing of the event has raised eyebrows, especially as it coincided with the release of hostages held by Hamas. Stefanik took to social media to express her outrage, stating, “On the eve of all the living hostages held by Hamas terrorists finally returning home, @KathyHochul endorsed Antisemite Communist NYC Mayor candidate is raising funds for an organization that participated in the October 7th terrorist attacks.”

This statement reflects a broader concern among some political factions regarding the implications of supporting organizations that may have ties to terrorist activities. Stefanik’s comments underscore the heightened sensitivities surrounding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, particularly in the wake of recent violence.

Historical Context of UNRWA

Established in 1949, UNRWA was created to provide assistance to Palestinian refugees following the Arab-Israeli conflict. Over the decades, the agency has been a focal point of controversy, particularly regarding its operations in Gaza. Reports have indicated that a significant number of UNRWA employees have been linked to Hamas or other militant groups. A November 2024 report from the Israeli non-profit organization IMPACT-se revealed that over 10% of UNRWA’s senior education staff in Gaza were affiliated with Hamas or the Palestinian Islamic Jihad.

The agency has faced accusations of failing to adequately vet its employees, leading to concerns about its role in perpetuating violence rather than alleviating it. Following the October 7 attacks, investigations revealed that several individuals involved in the planning and execution of the assault were on UNRWA’s payroll. In response, the agency terminated ten of the twelve staff members implicated in the attacks.

Political Ramifications

The fallout from Mamdani’s fundraising efforts has significant political implications, particularly as Stefanik prepares to challenge Hochul in the upcoming gubernatorial election. Stefanik has emerged as a prominent pro-Israel voice in Congress, and her criticisms of Mamdani reflect a broader strategy to galvanize support among constituents who prioritize national security and anti-terrorism measures.

Hochul’s endorsement of Mamdani has also drawn scrutiny. While she has expressed gratitude for the role of the Trump administration in securing the release of hostages, her failure to directly address the criticisms surrounding Mamdani has left her vulnerable to attacks from opponents. Stefanik’s comments highlight a growing divide within New York’s political landscape, particularly regarding the handling of issues related to Israel and Palestine.

Public Reactions and Broader Implications

The public response to Mamdani’s actions has been polarized. Supporters argue that fundraising for humanitarian efforts is essential, especially in conflict zones where civilians suffer the most. They contend that UNRWA plays a crucial role in providing necessary services, such as education and healthcare, to Palestinian refugees.

Conversely, critics assert that supporting an organization with alleged ties to terrorism undermines efforts to promote peace and security in the region. Irit Mizrahi Tratt, a former chair of the Trump47 Women’s Leadership Coalition, stated, “UNRWA employees participated in the October 7 massacre and kept hostages hidden in their homes. This is how you choose to spend your time on the eve of their release. I can’t say I’m surprised. What a disgrace.”

The debate surrounding Mamdani’s fundraising efforts reflects a broader discourse on the complexities of humanitarian aid in conflict zones. As the Israeli-Palestinian conflict continues to evolve, the role of organizations like UNRWA remains contentious, with implications for both local and international politics.

Conclusion

As the New York City mayoral race heats up, the controversy surrounding Zohran Mamdani’s fundraising for UNRWA highlights the intricate interplay between humanitarian efforts and political agendas. With figures like Elise Stefanik vocalizing their opposition, the implications of Mamdani’s actions extend beyond the immediate political landscape, touching on broader themes of national security, humanitarian aid, and the ongoing Israeli-Palestinian conflict. As the election approaches, how candidates navigate these sensitive issues will likely play a pivotal role in shaping voter sentiment and the future of New York City governance.