College Football’s New Coordinators: A Midseason Evaluation
As the 2025 college football season progresses, the impact of new coordinators across various programs is becoming increasingly evident. With teams like Miami and Florida State making significant changes to their coaching staff, the landscape of college football is shifting. This article delves into the performance of first-year coordinators, evaluating their contributions and the overall state of their respective teams.
Miami’s Defensive Revamp
After a disappointing end to the 2024 season, where Miami failed to secure a spot in the College Football Playoff despite boasting the nation’s top quarterback and offense, head coach Mario Cristobal made a pivotal decision. He brought in Corey Hetherman, a defensive coordinator previously with Minnesota, to revitalize a struggling defense. Under Hetherman’s guidance, Miami has transformed into a formidable unit, ranking ninth nationally in points allowed, with an impressive average of just 11.5 points per game.
Hetherman’s defensive strategy has effectively harnessed the talents of established players like Rueben Bain Jr., who has recorded two sacks and an interception this season. The Hurricanes have excelled against the run, allowing only 76.3 yards per game. Cristobal praised Hetherman’s teaching ability and the physicality his players now exhibit, stating, “Our guys have learned a lot of football. They’re playing with physicality and communicating at a much higher level.” This transformation has reignited hope for Miami fans, who are eager to see their team return to national prominence.
Florida State’s Offensive Overhaul
In contrast, Florida State faced a tumultuous 2024 season, finishing with a dismal 2-10 record. Head coach Mike Norvell responded by overhauling his coaching staff, hiring Gus Malzahn as the offensive coordinator and Tony White to lead the defense. Malzahn’s arrival has already paid dividends, as Florida State leads the nation in scoring, averaging 53 points per game. His innovative play-calling has kept defenses guessing, and the Seminoles have shown a remarkable ability to convert on critical downs.
Despite a recent setback against Virginia, where Florida State struggled with turnovers, Malzahn’s offensive scheme has showcased the talents of players like quarterback Tommy Castellanos and wide receiver Duce Robinson. Norvell expressed confidence in Malzahn, stating, “I feel like I got one of the best playcallers in the country.” The combination of Malzahn’s experience and the talent on the roster has revitalized the Seminoles, making them a team to watch as the season unfolds.
The Broader Impact of New Coordinators
Miami and Florida State are not alone in their coaching changes. Other programs have also made significant adjustments, with varying degrees of success. Oklahoma, for instance, has seen a resurgence in its offense after hiring Ben Arbuckle as the offensive coordinator. Arbuckle, who previously worked with quarterback John Mateer at Washington State, has helped the Sooners achieve a 4-0 start, although they rank only 59th nationally in scoring.
Texas Tech has also made headlines with its new coordinators, Shiel Wood and Mack Leftwich. Under their leadership, the Red Raiders have improved dramatically, allowing just 11.3 points per game and averaging 52 points on offense. Coach Joey McGuire emphasized the importance of these hires, stating, “We’re not rebuilding. You need to understand we’re putting all this money in. You’ve got to be ready to go.”
Meanwhile, Notre Dame is grappling with its own challenges under first-year defensive coordinator Chris Ash. Despite high expectations, the Irish defense has struggled, allowing significant yardage and points in key games. Head coach Marcus Freeman has remained supportive of Ash, emphasizing the need for collective improvement.
Evaluating Performance: Midseason Grades
As the season reaches its midpoint, it’s time to assess the performance of these new coordinators. Here’s a breakdown of their contributions so far:
Corey Hetherman, Miami – Grade: A
Hetherman has revitalized Miami’s defense, turning it into one of the best in the nation. His ability to maximize talent and instill discipline has been crucial for the Hurricanes.
Gus Malzahn, Florida State – Grade: A
Malzahn’s offensive creativity has transformed Florida State into a scoring powerhouse. His experience and strategic acumen have made a significant impact on the team’s performance.
Ben Arbuckle, Oklahoma – Grade: B+
While Oklahoma’s offense has improved, it still has room for growth. Arbuckle’s leadership has been commendable, but consistency remains a concern.
Shiel Wood and Mack Leftwich, Texas Tech – Grade: A
Both coordinators have made an immediate impact, leading Texas Tech to impressive defensive and offensive statistics. Their ability to adapt and innovate has been key to the team’s success.
Chris Ash, Notre Dame – Grade: D+
Ash’s defense has struggled to meet expectations, and the team’s performance has suffered as a result. Improvement is necessary for the Irish to remain competitive.
Conclusion
The 2025 college football season has already showcased the significant impact that new coordinators can have on their programs. As teams like Miami and Florida State make strides toward reclaiming their former glory, the effectiveness of these coaching changes will continue to be scrutinized. With the season still unfolding, fans and analysts alike will be watching closely to see how these new leaders shape the future of their respective teams. The landscape of college football is ever-evolving, and the decisions made in the coaching ranks will undoubtedly play a pivotal role in determining the outcomes of the season.
