Since his debut in Major League Baseball (MLB) in 2016, Aaron Judge has emerged as one of the most formidable sluggers in the game, captivating fans and instilling fear in pitchers across the league. Standing at an imposing 6-foot-7 and weighing 282 pounds, Judge’s combination of size, power, and plate discipline has made him a nightmare for opposing pitchers. With 359 home runs to his name, he leads all players since his entry into the league, and his presence at the plate is enough to electrify an entire stadium.
Despite facing a midseason elbow injury that hampered his performance, Judge is on track to finish another stellar season, with over 40 home runs and an OPS exceeding 1.000. As the season winds down, he finds himself once again in contention for the American League MVP award, a title he claimed the previous year.
To gain insight into Judge’s impact, we reached out to pitchers who have faced him throughout his career, including those who encountered his power before he became a household name.
The Rise of a Legend
Every pitcher who steps onto the mound against Judge today is acutely aware of the challenge he presents. However, there was a time when he was relatively unknown, particularly during his college days at Fresno State. In 2012, Mark Appel, then a star pitcher for Stanford, faced Judge in a nonconference matchup. At that time, Judge had yet to make a significant mark in college baseball.
Appel recalls the limited scouting available, stating, “We knew just based off of the numbers, but it was so early in the season. I don’t think he had a prolific freshman year. He was relatively unknown to us.” However, Judge shocked Appel and the Stanford team by hitting two home runs in a stunning upset, marking the beginning of his ascent in the baseball world.
“We walked in there thinking we would steamroll them, but we were completely taken aback,” Appel said. “I had just come off a dominant game against Texas, and then I faced this Fresno State team that put up seven runs on me.”
Judge’s performance that day not only put him on the map but also set the stage for his future success. He was drafted in the first round the following year, and his legend continued to grow.
Memorable Encounters
Judge’s prowess was further solidified during his time in the Cape Cod League, where he faced some of the best collegiate pitchers in the country. Frederick Shepard, who pitched for the Wareham Gatemen, vividly remembers a game where Judge hit a home run that cleared the trees beyond the center-field fence. “It was one of those moments where you realize you’re facing a special talent,” Shepard said.
Another pitcher, Anthony Montefusco, recalled a similar experience. “I threw a fastball inside, and he turned on it. I mean, it had to be 500 feet,” he said, reflecting on the sheer power Judge displayed. “It was one of those home runs where you just have to tip your cap.”
These encounters not only highlight Judge’s incredible talent but also the lasting impressions he leaves on those who pitch against him. Many pitchers have shared stories of their experiences, often with a mix of awe and respect for his abilities.
The Mental Game
Facing Judge is not just a physical challenge; it’s a mental one as well. Pitchers must prepare meticulously, knowing that any mistake could lead to a home run. Max Fried, a pitcher for the New York Yankees, emphasized the importance of strategy when facing Judge. “He’s definitely the focal point of the lineup. You don’t want him to beat you,” he said.
Ryne Stanek, another pitcher, noted that many pitchers approach Judge with caution, often leading to mistakes. “People pitch him scared and then have to come back, which puts them at a disadvantage,” he explained. “He knows how to cover the plate and doesn’t chase bad pitches.”
Judge’s ability to remain calm and focused at the plate is a testament to his skill. He doesn’t overswing, which allows him to make solid contact with the ball, regardless of the pitch type. His statistics reflect this, as he has consistently ranked among the league leaders in various offensive categories since his debut.
Physical Presence
Judge’s physical stature adds another layer of complexity for pitchers. His height and reach make the strike zone appear larger, creating a unique challenge. “When he steps into the box, you really feel his presence,” said Sean Manaea, a pitcher for the New York Mets. “It’s hard not to notice how big he is.”
Blake Snell, a two-time Cy Young Award winner, has faced Judge numerous times and described the experience as daunting. “I tell him not to swing because when he does, it’s trouble,” Snell said. “He’s a physical specimen, and when he connects, it’s going a long way.”
Pitchers often find themselves in a mental battle, trying to navigate Judge’s impressive skill set while also managing their own nerves. The intimidation factor is real, and many pitchers have shared their experiences of feeling overwhelmed when facing him.
Home Run Memories
For pitchers, giving up home runs to Judge is an occupational hazard. Jason Adam, a reliever, recounted a moment when he thought he had surrendered a game-tying home run. “I could’ve sworn that ball was 60 rows deep,” he said, only to be relieved when the ball was caught at the warning track. “It was a hilarious moment because I thought I blew the game.”
Other pitchers have not been as fortunate. Chris Sale, for instance, recalled a home run Judge hit at Fenway Park that left a lasting impression. “It was one of those where you just know it’s gone as soon as it leaves the bat,” Sale said. “You just have to accept it.”
These stories illustrate the duality of facing a player like Judge: the thrill of competing against a top talent and the inevitable moments of defeat that come with it.
Conclusion
Aaron Judge has solidified his status as one of the premier hitters in baseball history. His combination of power, skill, and presence at the plate makes him a unique challenge for pitchers. As he continues to break records and earn accolades, the stories shared by those who have faced him serve as a testament to his impact on the game. Whether through awe-inspiring home runs or unforgettable encounters, Judge’s legacy is one that will be remembered for years to come.
