Scarlett Johansson‘s Directorial Debut: A Deep Dive into “Eleanor the Great“

Scarlett Johansson’s feature directorial debut, “Eleanor the Great,” premiered at the 2025 Cannes Film Festival and is set to hit theaters on September 26, 2025. The film explores the intricate dynamics of friendship, loss, and the complexities of human relationships, particularly as they evolve with age.

A Unique Friendship

At the heart of “Eleanor the Great” is the enduring friendship between Eleanor, portrayed by June Squibb, and her best friend Bessie, played by Rita Zohar. Their bond has lasted over seven decades, surviving the trials of life, including the loss of their husbands and the departure of their children. The two women share not just an apartment in sunny Florida but also a bedroom, with twin beds positioned side by side, symbolizing their deep connection. Their lives are intertwined, filled with shared routines like sorting bills, clipping coupons, and reminiscing about their pasts.

This portrayal of friendship among older women is a refreshing departure from the typical narratives often seen in mainstream cinema. It challenges societal norms that often overlook the lives and relationships of older individuals, particularly women.

The Journey of Loss and Renewal

The film’s narrative takes a poignant turn when Eleanor relocates to New York City to live with her adult daughter, Lisa (Jessica Hecht), and her grandson, Max (Will Price). This transition serves as a backdrop for Eleanor’s exploration of new friendships, particularly with Nina, a college student played by Erin Kellyman. The film delicately examines the emotional landscape of grief and the challenges of forming new connections after the loss of a significant person.

Johansson and screenwriter Tory Kamen delve into the complexities of Eleanor’s emotional state. The film raises critical questions about the nature of friendship and the human need for connection, especially in the face of loss. Eleanor’s journey is not just about finding a new friend; it is about navigating the void left by Bessie and the emotional baggage that comes with it.

The Complications of Deception

As Eleanor attempts to forge a new bond with Nina, she inadvertently finds herself in a web of deception. When she mistakenly enters a support group for Holocaust survivors-of which she is not a member-she pretends to share Bessie’s experiences. This lie, initially portrayed with humor, soon spirals into a complex moral dilemma. The film cleverly juxtaposes Eleanor’s well-meaning intentions with the ethical implications of her deception, creating a rich tapestry of emotional conflict.

The casting of actual Holocaust survivors in the support group adds a layer of authenticity and poignancy to the narrative. It serves as a reminder of the weight of history and the personal stories that shape our identities. Eleanor’s journey becomes a reflection on the nature of truth and the lengths to which individuals will go to connect with others.

Thematic Depth and Emotional Resonance

“Eleanor the Great” is not merely a light-hearted exploration of friendship; it grapples with profound themes of grief, identity, and the human condition. The film’s tone fluctuates between humor and sadness, capturing the complexities of life itself. Johansson’s direction, combined with Kamen’s sharp writing, creates a narrative that is both engaging and thought-provoking.

The relationship between Eleanor and Nina serves as a microcosm of the broader human experience. Both characters are defined by their losses-Nina by the recent death of her mother and Eleanor by the memories of her beloved friend Bessie. Their bond, forged in shared grief, highlights the universal need for connection and understanding.

Cinematic Aesthetics

The film’s cinematography, helmed by Hélène Louvart, adds to its emotional depth. The warm, inviting visuals create a sense of nostalgia, reminiscent of mid-budget studio films from a bygone era. This aesthetic choice enhances the film’s exploration of memory and the passage of time, inviting viewers to reflect on their own relationships and experiences.

Navigating the Final Act

As the narrative unfolds, Eleanor’s lies become increasingly complicated, involving Nina’s father, Roger (Chiwetel Ejiofor), a local news anchor whom Eleanor has long admired. This subplot introduces additional layers to the story, allowing for a broader exploration of grief and the human experience. However, the film’s final act struggles to reconcile its themes, leading to moments that may feel overly sentimental or predictable.

Despite these challenges, “Eleanor the Great” remains an ambitious endeavor. Johansson and Kamen’s willingness to tackle complex emotional landscapes is commendable, even if the execution occasionally falters. The film ultimately conveys a powerful message: it is never too late to seek new connections, and even imperfect attempts at friendship hold intrinsic value.

Conclusion

“Eleanor the Great” is a heartfelt exploration of friendship, loss, and the human experience, skillfully directed by Scarlett Johansson. While it navigates the complexities of deception and grief, the film ultimately celebrates the resilience of the human spirit. As Eleanor and Nina embark on their journey together, viewers are reminded of the importance of connection, regardless of age or circumstance. With its rich themes and emotional depth, “Eleanor the Great” promises to resonate with audiences, offering a poignant reflection on the nature of friendship and the enduring bonds that shape our lives.